Photo captions: 1) The body of Bishoy Nataay Boushra bore marks of brutal beatings. (Morning Star News). 2) Jeremy and Elma Reynalds.
Egyptian Army “Suicides” Raise Possibility of Persecution of Christians in Military
By Jeremy Reynalds, Senior Correspondent, ASSIST News Service (email@example.com)
ISTANBUL, TURKEY (ANS-Dec 15, 2015) — In a daze, Nataay Boushra made his way out of the morgue and into a hallway of the army hospital in Cairo, Egypt.
According to a story by Morning Star News, lost in grief, he walked through the hallways of the medical facility; past nurses, doctors and groups of young soldiers talking to each other, but he noticed nothing. His son was dead.
Bishoy. He kept repeating his son’s name in his mind like an incantation, willing him to come back to life. But his body, stripped of its soul, lay covered by a sheet on a drawer in a cadaver refrigerator. For Boushra, the pain was beyond comprehension.
“This kind of sadness,” he said tearfully 10 days later in tears, “It is worse than death. If we die in Christ, we are free, but to live in this grief – it is agony.”
On the morning of Nov. 20, Boushra was notified that his son, Private First Class Bishoy Nataay Boushra, a second-year conscript soldier in the Egyptian Army, was dead. He was 21.
Word of his son’s death was painful enough, but Morning Star News said it was compounded when military officials told him how he had died, “Suicide.”
The military’s claim of suicide sent Nataay Boushra spiraling in anger and disbelief. Never mind that his deeply spiritual son, a prospective Coptic Orthodox monk, considered suicide to be a grave sin, or that he was widely known in the army and in his village for being well adjusted and happy.
Neither was there a suicide letter or talk of depression before his death.
He was just three months away from being discharged from the army and pursuing his lifelong dream of becoming a monk. For whatever reason, Nataay Boushra said, someone in the army killed his son, and someone else was lying about it.
Bishoy Boushra was the third Christian this year, Egyptian human rights activists say, to die under suspicious circumstances while serving in the Egyptian military. The military claimed another Coptic Christian committed suicide in June. A third Christian, according to military officials, was killed in a shooting incident in August.
Morning Star News said the families of Boushra and the other soldier who reportedly committed suicide are openly questioning the military’s claims and say both men were murdered.
As for the shooting death in August, there is no publicly available record of any criminal charges being filed over the incident, and it has seemingly been lost, accidentally or otherwise, in Egypt’s legal system.
Bishoy Boushra and the two other Christians join a growing list of Coptic soldiers, their family members said, whom other soldiers have killed over the past few years, and whose deaths the government has covered up.
In order to avoid national embarrassment, Morning Star News reported many Copts say the government refuses to admit there is a problem of mistreatment of Christians in the military.
The denial is an extension of a larger issue in Egypt, Morning Star News claimed. The government refuses to admit there is a problem of mistreatment of Copts in Egypt as a whole, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
Discrimination and persecution of Christians in Egypt covers all elements of society, including the military, advocates say.
Mina Thabet, program manager at the Egyptian Commission for Rights and Freedoms (ECRF), said it is “hard to prove” that the government is directly persecuting Christians in the military. The army’s complete lack of transparency is the main problem, Thabet said.
“It is a usual thing for the government to cover up anything, and it makes the details of any problems that may exist unclear,” Thabet told Morning Star News.
“That usually happens when the issue is related to the army or the police. You will usually find them denying things, so people never know what is really happening.”
Thabet added that when the government issues information, officials expect the populous to accept it without questioning. Their attitude is, “If we say it is suicide, it is suicide – you have to take our story,” he said.
Morning Star News said multiple phone calls to the Egypt Armed Forces Media Center requesting comment on the issue went unanswered.
Evidence of Murder
In Jan. 2014, Bishoy Nataay Boushra was drafted into the Egyptian Army from the town of Mallawi, in Minya Governorate, for two years of service.
He was placed in the Central Security Forces (CSF), a ubiquitous, 450,000-man unit under the command of the Ministry of Interior used to augment the Egyptian National Police. Boushra was posted to the outskirts of Cairo, guarding the CSF barracks used by his duty section.
According to his family, he appeared to have adjusted well to military life but told friends and relatives he was looking forward to his discharge date on March 1 2016, so he could enter service in an Orthodox monastery.
“Ever since he was young, he had ambitions to become a monk and give his life to God, even deciding to skip college so he could finish school early along with his military service and go to a monastery to serve there,” Morning Star News reported Boushra’s father said.
Problems, family members said, came a few months ago when a fellow draftee, a Muslim known to the public only as “Mustafa,” began ridiculing Boushra for his faith.
Boushra endured months of threats, violence, intense verbal abuse and public humiliation without retaliating or even defending himself, his father said.
“After Bishoy was killed, one of his friends in his unit, a Christian, told me that Mustafa used to continuously harass Bishoy and pick fights with him,” he said. “But Bishoy would only say, ‘God forgives you, and I forgive you.’ But that only seemed to make Mustafa more angry with him.”
Boushra took the abuse in stride until Nov. 4, when the Muslim soldier launched into a tirade against Christianity, Christians and essentially everything Boushra believed about God, and he struck back, his father said.
“He was cursing Christ, Bishoy’s faith and the church, and that was the last straw, and Bishoy couldn’t take it anymore and hit him,” he said.
Boushra picked up a stick the size of an ax handle and hit the other soldier in the head, knocking him to the ground, according to court testimony.
Morning Star News said the soldier was taken to a hospital for examination and then released. Both men were arrested and placed together in a jail cell awaiting a hearing in a military court.
For reasons still unknown, another soldier who was a friend of Mustafa was later locked in the military prison cell with Boushra and Mustafa.
In a phone call to his father, Boushra talked about striking back.
“When he told me about what happened, I told him ‘Bishoy my son, we don’t respond in this way,’” Nataay Boushra, also Coptic Orthodox, said. Boushra agreed with his father but, clearly exasperated by the ordeal, told him, “I was so patient, and I have taken so much.”
According to the military, Boushra was found dead the morning of Nov. 20 in the bathroom of a military jail cell with a sheet wrapped around his neck. He had been waiting on a final court hearing on a misdemeanor charge stemming from the assault.
The judge was preparing to release both soldiers after they went through an informal judicial process in Egypt known as reconciliation, Morning Star News reported family members said.
The release, if approved would have happened on Nov. 25. If not approved, Boushra would probably have been sentenced to three months in prison and then released from military service as scheduled.
Officials told Nataay Boushra that his son killed himself by standing on an exposed water pipe, tying one end of a bed sheet around a window sill, wrapping the other end around his neck and jumping off the pipe.
The wounds on Boushra’s body, his father said, told a different story.
In addition to the ligature marks expected from a hanging or strangling death, Boushra’s torso was covered with bruises and huge welts from what appeared to be sustained, brutal beatings. Exactly how the bruises got there is a mystery.
The military made its ruling that the cause of death was a suicide before an autopsy was performed. At the morgue, Morning Star News reported, the family refused to take charge of the remains until officials conducted an autopsy.
The results of the autopsy, conducted the next day, are expected in roughly a month. It is unclear if the results will be released to the public or the family. Boushra’s remains were buried in Mallawi on Nov. 21.
During a court hearing on Nov. 18, the younger Boushra was able to meet with his uncle, Samy Boushra, who said that his nephew apologized in court for striking Mustafa and deeply regretted it, but that he was otherwise in good spirits.
Boushra’s uncle was the last family member to see him alive. Based on his nephew’s mental state during and after the court hearing, he does not think he committed suicide.
“He was very happy, and he seemed to be very calm and relaxed,” Samy Boushra said. “He was happy. He was looking forward to getting out of the army. There was nothing that would lead him to kill himself.”
Nataay Boushra said the military’s claim that his son killed himself is without basis. Father and son spoke to each other by phone two days before his death.
“I don’t understand – after hearing his voice, everything seemed well,” Morning Star News reported Nataay Boushra said. “Then after less than 48 hours, they call me and tell me he killed himself? What changed in that extra day to get him in that state? I don’t understand.”
The Boushras aren’t the only Coptic family seeking justice for relatives lost under suspicious circumstances while serving in the military.
In June, according to the military, soldiers found the body of Coptic conscript Bahaa Mikhail Silwanus slumped in a chair in an office on the base where he was posted in Suez Governorate.
Military officials said Silwanus committed suicide by shooting himself twice in the chest with a rifle that was found at his feet.
“What upset us was that some officers claimed that they found him with the gun between his legs and he was dead,” said Emad Nasih, Silwanus’ cousin. “And without doing an investigation, they closed the case and claimed there is no murderer.”
Silwanus was the only Coptic Christian soldier in his unit, members of his family said. Because of this, Silwanus told family members, he was harassed constantly.
There are parallels in the Boushra and Silwanus deaths. Morning Star News said officials put up roadblocks to keep the Silwanus family from obtaining an autopsy for their son, as they did with the Boushras. It wasn’t until almost two months after the death that officials allowed the Silwanus family to see a copy of the results of an autopsy the military conducted.
Silwanus also had unexplained marks on his body that raised serious questions about the military’s claim that he committed suicide. That besides the obvious question of how he could have shot himself twice in the chest, there was a large, deep contusion on the back of his head from an apparently recent beating.
Possibly the most striking parallel between the two soldiers was the similarity of their spiritual lives, and hence their families’ deep conviction that they did not commit suicide.
As with Boushra, Silwanus wanted to become an Orthodox monk when his military service was complete.
Mornign Star News reported that before he was drafted, Silwanus was a deacon and devoted much of his time to several ministries in his church, including its music ministry, teaching Sunday school to children and leading an outreach program to bring nominal Christians into relationship with God. Once in the army, Silwanus spent much of his off-duty time in private devotions.
“He used to pray and read the Bible all the time,” Silwanus’ cousin said.
The soldier’s Bible, his flute and his prayer book were the only personal items authorities handed over to Silwanus’ family. His prayer book, in his shirt pocket when he died, was covered with his blood.
The Silwanus family is still fighting to have another official investigation conducted into the death.
Along with the two alleged suicides, a Coptic soldier was shot this year in Marsa Matruh near Alexandria.
On Aug. 23, Baha Saeed Karam, 22, was shot four times by soldier Mohammed Tarek after an argument about religion during the month of Ramadan, when Muslims fast during the day, according to the military.
Karam was taken to a hospital in Alexandria but died sometime before he arrived. Tarek was arrested and, according to local media reports, admitted to shooting Karam, but no charges have been filed against him in the three months that have followed.
No other information is publicly available about the crime, Tarek or any possible charges against him.
As devastating as the loss of his son has been, Morning Star News reported Nataay Boushra said he learned a great deal about him after he died.
“He was loving to people and loved serving them,” Nataay Boushra said. “He loved God so much that he decided to give up all the earthly pleasures and give his life to Him. He used to work, then give most of what he earned to the needy and left very little for himself, just enough to get by. His life of serving others was all in secret, because he didn’t want to get glory on earth.”
For more information visit www.morningstarnews.org
About the writer: Jeremy Reynalds is Senior Correspondent for the ASSIST News Service, a freelance writer and also the founder and CEO of Joy Junction, New Mexico’s largest emergency homeless shelter, www.joyjunction.org. He has a master’s degree in communication from the University of New Mexico, and a Ph.D. in intercultural education from Biola University in Los Angeles. His newest book is “From Destitute to Ph.D.” Additional details on “From Destitute to Ph.D.” are available at www.myhomelessjourney.com. Reynalds lives in Albuquerque, New Mexico with his wife, Elma. For more information contact: Jeremy Reynalds at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Note: If you would like to help support the ASSIST News Service, please go to www.assistnews.net and click on the DONATE button to make your year-end tax-deductible gift (in the US), which will help us continue to bring you these important stories. If you prefer a check, please make it out to ASSIST and mail it to: PO Box 609, Lake Forest, CA 92609, USA. Thank you.
** You may republish this and any of our ANS stories with attribution to the ASSIST News Service (www.assistnews.net)